So I was having problems getting my headlight to retract and to come up completely. Also the button seemed to be recessed into the body work. I pulled the front cover off today and unbolted the headlight assembly to see whats what. I noticed the button is on a shaft which is spring loaded, It appears that the spring has slipped the C-clip retainer and made its way into the housing. I believe I could alleviate the problem if I could get the rubber button off to put a new spring on the shaft and a new retainer. I attached some pics to show whats going on.